Close
Sign in with your E-Mail & Password
Trending Articles
Featured Blogs

Dinosaur Battle Debate Round

6 RepliesAdd A Reply
Forum Topic

TheLazyFish

RespectedMember1630 XPFeb-02-2021 11:27 PM

Alright, I've seen that there has been really no activity here in the Dino forums since the last time I was active here... which was a year ago.

 

So, to spark up some kind of discussion, I want peoples' opinions on who would win the fights listed below, and reasons why.

 

A large (7 meters) Ceratosaurus magnicornis V.s. a small Allosaurus fragilis (8 meters) 

 

A 9 meter Tyrannosaurus subadult v.s. an Albertosaurus

 

Saurophaganax V Tarbosaurus

 

Tyrannotitan V Carcharodontosaurus

 

Stegosaurus V Mapusaurus

 

Tyrannosaurus V Shantungosaurus

If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.

6 Responses to Dinosaur Battle Debate Round

Sir_Caleb_

NoobMember98 XPFeb-03-2021 7:49 AM

I'll take the 1st one.

With this situation, I'd go with Allosaurus. Even though it's slightly larger, it still would be less bulky than the Ceratosaurus and could therefore run faster. Al also hunted in packs, which is a CLEAR sign of high intelligence.

"It's kind of fun to do the impossible." -Walt Disney

TheLazyFish

RespectedMember1630 XPFeb-03-2021 9:44 AM

I'm going to disagree with that. In my opinion, the Ceratosaurus would win. Estimates for Ceratosaurus magnicornis weight have been over 450 Kilograms, 700 Kilograms, and 980 Kilograms, and the most recent estimates I can find for the average Allosaurus fragilis are about 700 Kilograms as well. If we just use the middle-most weight in there to be fair, this means that the Ceratosaurus would still be a fair bit heavier than a small Allosaurus fragilis, while still being slightly more agile just due to being shorter in length. As for the running faster, that wouldn't be super important in most altercations. If this is simply a minor territorial battle, basing this off of Tyrannosaur intraspecific combat, they'd most likely bite each other on the faces, which would lend to Ceratosaurus' favor due to its enormous teeth and its superior bulk, giving it the edge in the battle. The Allosaurus' smaller teeth wouldn't be as good for this kind of situation, and the crests of the Ceratosaurus give it minor protection of it doing too much damage to the skull. In a fight to the death, the speed won't matter much because the Ceratosaurus' shorter length would make it slightly more agile or on par with it in terms of agility, so it wouldn't be able to run around the Ceratosaurus. Even if it did, the Ceratosaurus' back osteoderms would give some good protection against the Allosaurus' attacks to the back/spine, and it can muscle off the Allosaurus and begin to melee it. Due to its higher weight, it has the advantage there. Not only that, due to its shorter height in this case, Ceratosaurus would have the advantage of having a good shot at the Allosaurus' long, exposed neck, something its large, slashing teeth can take perfect advantage of. Allosaurus, being larger, has the disadvantage of having to bite down onto the Ceratosaurus from above, which is bad in this case because Ceratosaurus has osteoderms on its back to protect it from attacks like these. 

The main problem would be Allosaurus' claws, but I doubt that the arms could purely muscle off a heavier animal, and tearing it off the neck would do more damage to its neck in the long run. Not to mention, the arms won't be as good against Cerato's shorter, thicker neck compared to the enormous teeth or Cerato against Allo's longer and thinner neck. 

 

As for the pack hunting, I don't think there's much or any actual evidence of pack hunting in Allosaurs, and it's just a theory. I could be wrong, and if I am, can you show me a paper detailing the evidence or something like that? Thanks.

 

Even assuming higher intelligence, in a minor territory battle it won't make much difference, and a melee confrontation it won't be enough to give it an edge against a more robust creature. 

If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.

Accurate spino

NoobMember51 XPFeb-03-2021 1:38 PM

Well i think Mapusaurus would beat a stego but it would it in packs because thats how they hunt argintenosarus which are sauropods and they are huge so a stego would be easier but not with a herd mind you!

TheLazyFish

RespectedMember1630 XPFeb-03-2021 11:36 PM

A pack of Mapusaurus? Yeah that'd destroy a Stegosaurus, assuming they packed. Again, I don't think I've heard actual evidence of pack hunting in Mapusaurus but I could have just missed it. 

 

However, 1 on 1, I believe Stegosaurus would have the advantage despite its lighter weight. Its lower height would be an advantage in this case, because the Mapusaurus would be unable to attack its back very easily, only able to attack the flanks, head, and neck. Due to Mapusaurus' higher length and weight, and likely being slower or the same speed due to it, Stegosaurus should be able to keep its tail constantly facing the Mapusaurus. Either the Mapusaurus attacks, gets injured, and backs off, or it just gives up after being unable to out maneuver the Stegosaurus. 

If people weren't lazy, we wouldn't try to be efficient. If we weren't efficient, we'd never get anything done.

Die-hard Spino Fan

InitiateMember486 XPMar-21-2021 12:57 PM

Mapusaurus did hunt in packs they discovered a bunch of mapusauruses fossils in a bonebed dating all from the same time with argintinasaurus’ fossils also. 

That is one big pile of shit - Ian Malcom, 1993

Kamoebas V.6

InitiateMember267 XPMar-31-2021 11:05 AM

Hey Lazy fish,im Kamoebas V.6 or Ganimes V.8,you might not remember me.

 

1.Allosaurus wins this one easily tbh,i think you know why lol.  

2.As much as i hate T-Rex,i have to give it the w.

 

3.Saurophaganax easily.

 

4.Carchar by not much of a long shot,really close call.

 

5.Only if Mapu was in a pack would he win.

 

6.Another w for the Rex.

Add A Reply

Sign in to add a reply to this topic!

New Topics
Highest Forum Ranks Unlocked
Chris
Chris
98% To Next Rank
Martian
dk
dk
82% To Next Rank
Legend
Svanya
Svanya
86% To Next Rank
2K
Xenotaris
Xenotaris
54% To Next Rank
2K
Thoughts_Dreams
Thoughts_Dreams
76% To Next Rank
Respected
Support Us
Latest Activity
Member
Tips for Travelling with Close Friends just surpassed 1,000 views!
Member
Gojira Forces (Lim Chen Xi) just cast their vote on the Poll: Favorite sequel
Member
Three greatest movie adaptations of books just surpassed 1,000 views!

Find the best top 10 casino in Canada!

Scified is an entertainment media network covering the latest news on the most popular, upcoming science fiction movies, games and television. All content is property of Scified.com unless otherwise stated. Images and names of content we promote, discuss, review or report are property of their respective owners. Scified is independantly owned and operated by a team of dedicated sci-fi movie fans, who strive to provide the best information and community experience for other like-minded sci-fi movie enthusiasts.

© 2021 Scified.com